The Bulletin

News

Where do we go from here with the allegations about Christian Porter?

  • Written by Rick Sarre, Emeritus Professor of Law and Criminal Justice, University of South Australia

A great deal has been written and said in the last few days about the next steps in the historic claim of rape against Attorney-General Christian Porter.

There are mounting calls for an independent inquiry amid constant references to the decision of the NSW police to close their investigations. But our attention should now switch to the South Australian coroner. I’ll explain why.

How police decide a case can be pursued

One of the frequently asked questions about this case is how the NSW police prosecutors determined, seemingly very quickly and without questioning Porter, that they would not be proceeding with any more investigations — let alone criminal charges.

As far as they were concerned, the matter was now closed.

Why do NSW police have the final determination and how could they move so quickly? Well, the alleged victim was South Australian and the alleged perpetrator was Western Australian, but the assault was alleged to have taken place in NSW. Hence, it fell to that state’s police to make an investigation and consider their options.

At the early stages of any investigation, police are the “gatekeepers” for decisions that might lead to a prosecution. The guidelines used by police prosecutors are straightforward: they decide whether the evidence is capable of leading to a successful conviction, and whether it is in the public interest for a prosecution to proceed.

They do not, and cannot, go on “fishing” expeditions. They cannot launch a prosecution hoping something will emerge down the track that might lead to the conviction of the accused.

In this case, we can assume the police decided the fact the complainant was deceased (and could not give evidence) and that the alleged offence happened more than three decades ago provided too little evidence to go on.

In their statement, the police used the term “admissible evidence”. By that, one can assume, they meant any hearsay evidence that was not capable of being corroborated could not be taken into account.

Read more: Has Christian Porter been subjected to a 'trial by media'? No, the media did its job of being a watchdog[1]

The complainant’s testimony is not essential

It may seem to many that the idea of deciding not to proceed without questioning the alleged perpetrator was a little odd, but the discretion attached to pre-trial decision-making is broad.

It is important to note that the inability of a complainant to give evidence for any reason (including death) is not the end of the matter. I know of no jurisdiction in Australia where a prosecution will be abandoned solely on the lack of a complainant’s testimony.

That was not always the case. In days gone by, once a complainant withdrew his or her complaint, a prosecution was inevitably withdrawn.

Read more: View from The Hill: Despite his denial, Christian Porter will struggle with the 'Caesar's wife' test[2]

The rules of evidence have also been reformed to make it easier for prosecutors to lead at trial with evidence of the propensity of an accused to commit offences of a sexual nature.

Nevertheless, the chances of a prosecution in a sexual offence case leading to a conviction remain slim.

As criminologist Kathleen Daly pointed out[3] a decade ago, of 100 complaints recorded by the police in Australia at that time, only 28% proceeded past the police to prosecution, 20% were finally prosecuted at trial, and only 11.5% resulted in convictions to any sexual offence. It would not be too much different now.

Over to the coroner

So where to from here? There have been calls for the launching of some form of inquiry into the entire matter from a number of quarters, including some MPs, the bereaved family and their friends.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has made it very clear[4] such an inquiry is not going to take place, and that is his, and no one else’s, political judgement call to make.

Where do we go from here with the allegations about Christian Porter? Morrison has dismissed calls for an inquiry into a historical rape allegation against Porter. Darren Pateman/AAP

But those seeking some form of external review can take heart from the words of South Australia Coroner David Whittle on Wednesday[5]:

On the morning of 1 March 2021, an investigation file regarding the death of a woman in June 2020 was delivered to me by South Australia Police. The woman’s death and related matters have been the subject of media reporting in recent days. Whilst SAPOL has provided information to me, I determined that the investigation is incomplete. This was particularly evident having regard to information contained in recent media reports.

The coroner has yet to decide whether to hold an inquest. He awaits further investigation by SA Police. But if he does, his power to draw matters to his attention, including from the statements of witnesses he may call (but not compel), is considerable.

Read more: Women are (rightly) angry. Now they need a plan[6]

It is not the state coroner’s role to establish whether a crime has been committed or to find a person guilty of that crime. But the coroner has considerable power fashioned over the centuries to get behind matters and dig deep. Remember, too, he is not bound by the rules of evidence.

The story has not ended just yet.

If this article has raised issues for you, or if you’re concerned about someone you know, call the 1800 Respect national helpline on 1800 737 732 or Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Read more https://theconversation.com/where-do-we-go-from-here-with-the-allegations-about-christian-porter-156497

The Conversation

News Bulletin

We studied 50 years of royal commissions — here's how they make a difference

Joel Carrett/AAPOn Monday, Scott Morrison announced a royal commission into veteran suicides — the fourth royal commission set up under his prim...

Michael Mintrom, Professor, Monash University - avatar Michael Mintrom, Professor, Monash University

Hydrogen and carbon capture receive extra funding, as Morrison prepares for Biden summit

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has announced next month’s budget will include a further $539.2 million government investment in new clean hydroge...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Media need to reframe their representation of Aboriginal deaths in custody

Cultural warning: This article contains names and images of deceased Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. This article also contains link...

Amanda Porter, Senior Fellow (Indigenous Programs), The University of Melbourne - avatar Amanda Porter, Senior Fellow (Indigenous Programs), The University of Melbourne

Forget JobKeeper — what the government and the country need now is a JabMaker plan

originalForget last week’s healthy 5.6% unemployment rate. It might be “comfortably below” the Coalition’s 6% threshold for co...

Mark Kenny, Professor, Australian Studies Institute, Australian National University - avatar Mark Kenny, Professor, Australian Studies Institute, Australian National University

Net zero won't be achieved in inner city wine bars: Morrison

As Scott Morrison gradually pivots his climate policy towards embracing a target of net zero emissions by 2050, he is seeking to distinguish the g...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Dutton humiliates defence force chief Angus Campbell over citation

Peter Dutton has begun his tenure as defence minister by delivering a very public slap to his most senior military adviser, chief of the Australia...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

9 Australians fighting for gender equality and making a difference

Stephen Saphore/AAPIt feels like every day brings more harrowing claims of harassment, bullying and abuse of women in our community.In the space of ju...

Blair Williams, Research Fellow, Global Institute for Women's Leadership (GIWL), Australian National University - avatar Blair Williams, Research Fellow, Global Institute for Women's Leadership (GIWL), Australian National University

Without evidence of real progress, NZ’s foreign policy towards China looks increasingly empty

www.shutterstock.comVery recently in the Bay of Bengal a naval exercise took place involving India, France, Japan and Australia. While it received lit...

Alexander Gillespie, Professor of Law, University of Waikato - avatar Alexander Gillespie, Professor of Law, University of Waikato

Writers Wanted



News Co Media

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion