Frank Brennan on rewording Voice question

Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Frank Brennan has been involved over decades in the big debates in Indigenous affairs. A Jesuit priest and an academic expert on the constitution, Brennan has advocated for recognising First Nations peoples in that document.

Supplied/Frank Brennan, Author provided But he has concerns about the breadth of Anthony Albanese’s proposed referendum question, arguing in his new book that its reference to the Voice making representations to executive government raises the prospect of many legal challenges. This issue of the potential for legal challenges is one that divides legal experts, with a number of authorities maintaining there is no problem. In this podcast, Brennan elaborates on why he believes the referendum question should be reworded and the form he thinks the question should take. Anthony Albanese’s proposed wording is: “There shall be a body, to be called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice. "The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice may make representations to Parliament and the Executive government on matters relating to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples. "The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws with respect to the composition, functions, powers and procedures of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice.” Frank Brennan’s suggested wording is: “There shall be an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice with such structure and functions as the Parliament deems necessary to facilitate consultation prior to the making of special laws with respect to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, and with such other functions as the Parliament determines.”

If challenged in court, Australia’s system of negative gearing might not survive
ShutterstockWhile Labor resists calls to change Australia’s system of negative gearing and the Greens push for changes, there’s a chance change could come from somewhere else altogether – Australia’s legal…
Pay transparency would help close NZ’s gender gap – why is progress so slow?
Getty ImagesAnnouncing her government’s plan to disestablish the Equal Pay Taskforce in May, Minister for the Public Service Nicola Willis argued the “process for settling pay equity claims has now…
Workers hate office noise – but is using headphones to shut out colleagues the solution?
ShutterstockIs it OK to wear headphones in the office? Do they help get work done, or is wearing them considered rude and damaging to the office vibe.While it might be…
HomeBuilder might be the most-complex least-equitable construction jobs program ever devised
HomeBuilder[1] is a good idea gone bad. It is possibly the most complex and least equitable program the government could have devised to deliver construction jobs. It gives $25,000 to people…